Volume II, Issue 9
November-December 2007
 


 main page :: middle grade   
For the Younger Middle Grade Reader

Blast to the Past: Betsy Ross's Star
by Stacia Deutsch and Rhody Cohon, illustrated by Guy Francis

Reviewed by Julie M. Prince

It's Monday and history club will meet after school as usual. But, nothing's really "usual" with this history club. Abigail and her three friends are off on another adventure going back in time to stop Babs Magee from taking a place in history that she hasn't earned.

Babs has already tried to steal the good works and ideas of George Washington and Ben Franklin, among others. Now, she's trying to take the page from the history book that says Betsy Ross sewed the first American flag. The kids need to prove that it was Betsy Ross, not Babs Magee who performed this important task. But wait, was it Betsy Ross?

Anyone who knows of the controversy surrounding Betsy Ross's place in American history will appreciate the undertaking of these adventurous authors. This book explores the evidence and shows kids how historians gather information and why it's important to document history, all with a fun tale that will keep kids intrigued!

Martin Bridge: Out of Orbit
by Jessica Scott Kerrin, illustrated by Joseph Kelly

Reviewed by Jennifer Rothschild, Biblio File

The latest volume in the adventures of Martin Bridge gives the reader another two tales about Martin, a sort of elementary aged every-boy. In the first, Martin's classmate Harper, is always telling outlandish lies that Martin's friends actually believe—things like Harper is getting a jet pack bike or that his father is really a spy. Although it is not explored in the context of the story, Martin's main annoyance with this is that Harper's stories often steal attention away from Martin. However, we do explore why Harper tells the tales he does. In the end, Harper's story-telling is as very useful skill to have.

In the second story, Martin gets hurt while trying to emulate his favorite superhero, Zip Rideout. This prompts much soul-searching as to why comic book heroes and TV characters never get hurt, although they are often involved in situations where injury is bound to happen. Luckily, the creator of Zip Rideout is coming to school, so Martin can ask him some very pointed questions.

Kelly's black-and-white graphite and charcoal illustrations break up the text nicely and add to the story—especially when illustrating how Martin pogo-sticks out of his tree house.

The Rising Star of Rusty Nail
by Lesley M.M. Blume

Reviewed by Alice Herold, Big A little a

The Rising Star of Rusty Nail, by Lesley M.M. Blume, is set in 1953. The main character, ten-year-old Franny, lives with her parents and two older brotehrs. This book was fun for me to read because I was Franny's age in 1953. Children practiced "duck and cover" in elementary school in case the "Commies" aimed a nuclear bomb at the Midwest. I remember being terrified, shaking under my desk. There are references to Roy Rogers, Ava Gardner, and other movie stars which triggered memories of playing with my paper dolls. There are mentions of candy cigarettes, wax lips, and Beeman's gum which reminded me of trips to the candy store across from my elementary school. The author has done her research.

Franny learns that life is filled with coincidences that later seem like fate. She feels like success comes from being in the right place at the right time. For example, a "commie" moves to Rusty Nail. Her name is Madame Malenkov (Olga). Later we learn Olga is hiding while posing as a lawyer's wife. Olga's father once owned (and willed to Olga) one of the finest rare instrument collections in Russia. Her piano, for example, was given to her by the famous pianist, Arthur Rubenstein. Franny begs Olga to give her piano lessons which she does in return for help around the house. Olga sees the potential in Franny and arranges for her to have an audition with Madame Svetlana Oblonsky, a teacher at the Julliard School. Franny was in the right places at the right times!

Readers can learn a great deal about music by reading The Rising Star of Rusty Nail. The book is divided into three sections: "Moderato" sets the stage; "Adagio," named for a concerto's second movement, for when the tension slowly builds; and "Allegro," the dramatic culmination. We learn about Rachmaninoff, whose music is dark and tumultuous. The author offers a detailed explanation of the workings of the inside of a piano and compares it to the inside of a hand. Olga is pleased Franny has wide hands which are needed to play Rachmaninoff.

I really enjoyed this story. The Rising Star of Rusty Nail is entertaining as well as informative.

Books Reviewed:

Blast to the Past: Betsy Ross's Star, by Stacia Deutsch and Rhody Cohon, illustrated by Guy Francis.
Simon & Schuster Children's Publishing, 2007. ISBN: 1-4169-3388-5.
Martin Bridge: Out of Orbit, by Jessica Scott Kerrin, illustrated by Joseph Kelly. Kids Can Press,
2007. ISBN: 1-5545-3149-3.
The Rising Star of Rusty Nail, by Lesley M.M. Blume. Random House Children's Books, 2007.
ISBN: 0-3758-3524-7.